OVERVIEW
Intellectual Property Rights refer to the legal rights that protect the creations of the human mind, such as inventions, literary and artistic works, symbols, names, images, and designs. IPRs are granted to the creators or owners of such intellectual property, and they enable them to control the use, distribution, and commercial exploitation of their creations.
The main types of IPRs include patents, trademarks, copyrights, trade secrets, and industrial designs. Each of these forms of intellectual property provides different forms of protection and legal rights to their owners. For example, patents grant the exclusive right to make, use, and sell an invention, while trademarks protect distinctive signs, such as logos or brand names, that are used to identify products or services in the marketplace.
IPRs play a crucial role in promoting innovation and creativity, as they provide incentives for individuals and businesses to invest in the development of new and useful products and services. They also help to ensure that the creators of intellectual property are appropriately rewarded for their efforts and that their rights are respected and protected in the marketplace.
DEFINITION OF TRADE SECRET AND PATENT
Trade secrets and patents are two types of intellectual property rights that provide legal protection to the owners of valuable information, ideas, and innovations. In India, both trade secrets and patents are governed by separate laws that outline their scope, requirements, and protections.
A trade secret is a confidential piece of information that is used in a business or commercial context and that provides a competitive advantage to the owner. It can be any type of confidential information, such as formulas, designs, processes, customer lists, or marketing strategies, that is not generally known or easily discoverable by others. Trade secrets can be protected under the Indian law through the provisions of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 which recognizes the enforceability of contracts that include confidentiality clauses, and the Indian law of torts, which allows for legal action against misappropriation or unauthorized disclosure of trade secrets.
A patent is defined under Section 2(1)(m) of the Patents Act, 1970 which means for any invention granted under this Act; It is a legal document that grants an inventor the exclusive right to manufacture, use, and sell an invention for a certain period of time, typically 20 years from the date of filing. To be eligible for a patent in India, an invention must be new, non-obvious, and useful, and it must be capable of industrial application. Patents in India are governed by the Patents Act, 1970, which provides for the filing, examination, and enforcement of patents.
ADVANTAGES OF PATENTS
1. Legal Protection: The primary advantage of patents is that they provide legal protection for a fixed period, during which the patent owner can prevent others from using, making, or selling their invention without permission. This gives the inventor the exclusive right to commercially exploit the invention and to take legal action against any infringement of the patent.
For instance, in the case of F. Hoffmann-La Roche Ltd. v. Cipla Ltd., RFA OS92/2012 the Delhi High Court held that Roche's patent over its drug Tarceva was valid and enforceable. The court found that Cipla's generic version of the drug infringed Roche's patent and ordered Cipla to stop selling it.
2. Increased Value: Patents can also increase the value of a company, as they can be licensed or sold to other businesses. This can generate significant revenue for the company and improve its market position. For example, Tata Motors holds patents for its fuel-efficient engines, which have increased the company's value and helped it to compete in the global automobile market.
3. Encourages Innovation: Patents encourage innovation by providing inventors with an incentive to invest time and resources in developing new and useful inventions. The exclusivity and legal protection provided by patents can motivate inventors to take risks and explore new areas of research and development.
For example, Indian company Haffkine Bio-Pharmaceutical Corporation developed a vaccine for Cholera, which was granted a patent by the Indian Patent Office in 2019. This patent encouraged the company to continue investing in the development of life-saving vaccines.
DISADVANTAGES OF PATENTS
1. Expensive and Time-consuming: Obtaining a patent can be a long and expensive process. In India, the cost of obtaining a patent can range from INR 15,000 to INR 1 lakh, depending on the complexity of the invention. This cost may be prohibitive for small businesses and individual inventors.
For example, in the case of Satyam Infoway Ltd. v. Siffynet Solutions Pvt. Ltd. (2004 (6) SCC 145), the Supreme Court of India held that the patent for a method of e-commerce was not valid, as it did not meet the requirements of novelty and inventive step. However, the court also noted that the cost of obtaining a patent in India was a significant barrier for small businesses and individual inventors.
2. Limited Duration: Patents have a limited duration, typically 20 years from the date of filing. After this period, the invention enters the public domain, and anyone can use, make, or sell it without permission. This can result in competitors replicating the invention after the patent expires, reducing the exclusive rights of the inventor.
For example, the patent for the drug Gleevec, which was granted to Novartis in 1993, expired in 2013. This allowed other companies to develop generic versions of the drug, which reduced Novartis' market share and revenue.
3. Hinders Free Flow of Information: Patents can also hinder the free flow of information and restrict access to essential goods and services. In some cases, patents can prevent the development of cheaper and more effective treatments or technologies, particularly in the field of healthcare.
For example, in the case of Bayer Corporation v. Union of India, WP 1323 of 2013, the Indian Patent Office granted a patent to Bayer for its cancer drug Nexavar. However, the price of the drug was prohibitively high, which led the Indian government to issue a compulsory license to Natco Pharma, allowing them to produce a generic version of the drug at a significantly lower cost.
ADVANTAGES OF TRADE SECRETS
1. Indefinite Protection: One of the biggest advantages of trade secrets is that they offer indefinite protection as long as the information remains confidential. Unlike patents, which have a fixed duration, trade secrets can be protected for as long as the owner can keep the information secret.
2. Lower Costs: Trade secrets are less expensive to protect than patents, as there are no registration or maintenance fees associated with them. This makes them an attractive option for small businesses or start-ups with limited budgets.
3. Greater Flexibility: Trade secrets offer greater flexibility than patents, as there are no restrictions on the type of information that can be protected. This means that trade secrets can protect a wide range of information, including technical know-how, customer lists, and marketing strategies.
DISADVANTAGES OF TRADE SECRETS
1. Difficult to Enforce: Trade secrets can be difficult to enforce, as they are entirely dependent on the owner's ability to keep the information confidential. Once a trade secret is disclosed, the owner loses its protection, and they have no legal recourse.
2. Limited Remedies: The remedies available for trade secret misappropriation are limited compared to those available for patent infringement. In India, the remedies available for trade secret misappropriation include injunctions, damages, and account of profits.
3. Risk of Accidental Disclosure: Trade secrets are at risk of accidental disclosure, as they can be inadvertently revealed by employees or third-party contractors. This can result in the loss of the competitive edge and damage to the business's reputation.
RELEVANT CASE LAWS
1. In the case of Tata Consultancy Services Ltd v. State of Andhra Pradesh, Appeal (civil) 2582 of 1998 Tata had developed a unique e-procurement system for the Andhra Pradesh government, which was protected as a trade secret. However, the government disclosed the information to a third-party contractor, resulting in the misappropriation of Tata's trade secret. The High Court of Andhra Pradesh granted an injunction to prevent the government from using Tata's trade secrets in the development of a new e-procurement system.
2. In the case of Pepsico India Holdings Pvt. Ltd. v. Hindustan Coca Cola Ltd. WP 94 of 2001, Pepsico alleged that Coca Cola had misappropriated its trade secrets related to the manufacture of soft drinks. Pepsico claimed that Coca Cola had hired several of its former employees who had access to confidential information and had used that information to develop a competing product. The Delhi High Court granted an injunction in favour of Pepsico and ordered Coca Cola to pay damages for the misappropriation of trade secrets.
TRADE SECRETS VS PATENT
Trade secrets and patents are two distinct forms of intellectual property protection recognized under Indian law. Here are some key differences between the two:
1. Definition and Scope:
I. Trade secret: A trade secret is any confidential information or know-how that has commercial value and is not generally known or readily available to the public. It can include formulas, designs, processes, techniques, or any other confidential information that gives a business a competitive advantage.
II. Patent: A patent is a legal monopoly granted by the government to an inventor for a limited period of time (usually 20 years from the date of filing) in exchange for disclosing the invention to the public. Patents protect new and useful inventions, processes, machines, articles of manufacture, and compositions of matter.
2. Duration of Protection:
I. Trade secret: The protection for a trade secret can last as long as the confidential information remains secret and provides a competitive advantage. However, if the secret is revealed to the public or becomes generally known, the protection ends.
II. Patent: The protection for a patent lasts for a limited period of time, usually 20 years from the date of filing. Once the patent expires, the invention becomes part of the public domain and can be freely used by anyone.
3. Registration and Disclosure:
I. Trade secret: Unlike patents, trade secrets are not registered with any government agency. In fact, disclosing a trade secret to the government or filing a patent application may destroy its status as a trade secret. It is the responsibility of the trade secret owner to maintain its confidentiality.
II. Patent: In order to obtain a patent, an application must be filed with the Indian Patent Office, and the invention must meet certain criteria of novelty, non-obviousness, and industrial applicability. Once a patent is granted, the invention is publicly disclosed in the patent document.
4. Enforcement:
I. Trade secret: Trade secret protection is enforced through civil law, and the burden of proof is on the trade secret owner to show that the information is confidential and has been misappropriated by someone else. In India, trade secret misappropriation is covered under the Indian Contract Act, 1872, and the Information Technology Act, 2000.
II. Patent: Patent protection is enforced through civil and criminal law, and the burden of proof is on the patent owner to show that the invention has been infringed upon by someone else. In India, patent infringement is covered under the Patents Act, 1970.
CONCLUSION
In conclusion, Indian law recognizes both trade secrets and patents as viable means of protecting confidential information and inventions. The choice between trade secrets and patents in India depends on various factors, such as the novelty of the invention, the duration of protection, the level of disclosure required, and the cost involved.
While trade secrets may be more cost-effective and do not require registration fees, they require ongoing expenses to maintain confidentiality. Patents, on the other hand, provide a higher level of protection, are publicly disclosed, and have a fixed duration of protection. Ultimately, the choice between trade secrets and patents in India depends on the specific circumstances of the invention or confidential information, and legal advice should be sought to determine the best course of action.
Comments